Well it was like that last year mate! And you passed it then…

Barry Babister from MOT Juice throws some light on warning lights

Published:  28 June, 2018

How many warning lights does it take to create an MOT fail? Put simply, just one - but how many choices do we have?  
    
Looking through the revised testing manual it’s hard pick out these faults amongst so many changes. Let’s see if we can summarise them for you as a refresher on what fails, some new and some old. Below is a list of
major failures:

  •  ABS warning device MIL indicates a malfunction
  •  EBS warning device MIL indicates a malfunction
  •  Electronic parking brake MIL indicates a malfunction
  •  Brake pad or lining wear indicator illuminated
  •  EPS MIL indicating a system malfunction
  •  A towbar coupling indicator not working    
  •  An SRS MIL indicates a system malfunction
  •  ESC MIL indicates a system malfunction        
  •  Engine MIL inoperative or indicating a malfunction


Managing the process
These new fail items will create much more work for the workshop, but how to best manage this process?
At our garages, we have already refined our process for what will be an influx of fresh failures created by the additional fail items. Here are some thoughts on the repair process from our workshop team, but first a word of warning; ‘MIL lights will rarely be a simple cheap fix.’

Most of these warning lamps (MIL) will really only be the headline to the actual underlying fault. Yes we can sell a fault code read, which we offer as a read and report at £45, but without actually defining the true cause of the fault then a ‘fault code read and report’ does little more that the fail sheet.

A better solution is to upsell a proper diagnostic process that will allow the workshop to drill into the fault and present the customer with an estimate of repair options. Typically, we will charge one hour for this process, consisting of around 35 minutes of diagnostic process (which might include fault code read/record/clear, road test, and parts testing to gain an understanding of the route cause of the fail items) sufficient enough to give good guidance to front office for building a quotation.  

Often, we need to request further diagnostic time from the customer at this stage, as we need to work as far as possible to the route cause and the resolution of the fault and any associated underlying issues that are affecting the fault. It is better to take time to diagnose and quote correctly that to try and help a customer to a cheaper resolution that does not really address the fault.  
This is the stage that the job is pushed back at reception who are tasked with laying out the options to the customer, never forget; “its not your car!” So tell the customer what you have found and what it will cost to repair. The rest is their decision.
To download a factsheet on the new MOT fails click here.

Related Articles

  • T.Q.I. or T.Q. WHY?  

    Here is an extract from the sixth edition of the Testing Guide:
    “E3 Ongoing Requirements: Testers should access their Test Quality Information (TQI) Reports via the MOT Testing Service (MTS), to compare their personal performance with the national averages. This is relevant to the tester as it is an ongoing requirement of authorisation.”
        
    Let’s explore what the DVSA want to achieve. The DVSA need to be accountable to Government for ensuring the MOT Scheme is well run and managed. They themselves cannot be in all places at all times, so by running a TQI comparison they are able to gain a structured insight on the performance of each and every MOT tester. They can then compare each individual MOT tester’s results against the national average and can use this system to identify any anomalies.  In essence, the DVSA need this information to prove they are managing the scheme and to identify where any weaknesses might be found.

    Insider information
    How can the DVSA use the information? As MOT testing stations we previously had this data available via an earlier version of the VTS software along with a scoring system. Now just because we don’t see the scoring system please do not think for one moment that the DVSA cannot see your scores.
        
    When a DVSA Vehicle Examiner (VE) is sat down the road from your garage, he is able to look at the TQI of each tester and arrive at your reception area armed with what could be termed ‘insider information’, although the information that the DVSA can see is the same information you can access via your TQI.
        
    Worse still if your TQI percentages are consistently too far from the national  average, a computer at the DVSA could alert your local DVSA office and create the need for a Vehicle Examiner to visit your garage unannounced.

    Review and manage  
    The DVSA have given us all the ability to be armed against any weaknesses in our TQI and via the new directive are actually forcing us to review and manage our own TQI. Let’s not forget the DVSA need to have a well-run scheme, so by forcing us to review and manage the TQI they are keeping themselves in good shape too.
        How often should you check your TQI? Let’s make this simple you should check it every month. What should you do with your TQI? Each tester (not your employer or AE) should check their own TQI each month. Once you have your TQI report, you should check your own averages against the national averages. If all of your TQI is close to the national average then you have very little to be concerned about, and the DVSA will also have no concerns here.
        Importantly, in order to remain compliant you should have a record of checking your TQI and be able to produce that record to the DVSA on demand. If you have checked, all is good, and you have documented this check, then well done.
        What if your TQI is bad? Two things can happen here:
    1. You are a BAD tester and you probably get found out, or...

    2. You are a GOOD tester with bad TQI who needs to put things right.

    The DVSA want us all to work to a quality management scheme (QMS). The DVSA want to see that we all manage our VTS correctly. They expect us to do this by continually checking and measuring ourselves against a set of standards. Now the DVSA are not silly and they know that there will be shortcomings and things that go wrong. In fact, they expect just that, and even encourage it. What the DVSA want is for all of our checking to be recorded, then they want us to find things that are wrong and record them. More importantly they want us to put those things right and record when they have been corrected.
        
    Returning to our bad TQI, it is safe to say that the DVSA will want to know that we have identified the issue and recorded that problem, then we need to supply a solution and document that solutions outcome.
        
    Finding a valid reason for your TQI differences is often down to unique circumstances, some real-world examples that come to mind are:

  • New Sun One-Person Testing Car Scissor Lift 

    The new Sun SSL 6350 scissor lift can be installed into current MOT bay recesses to replace older four-post lifts – and requires no additional groundworks.  The inclusion of shaker plates gives the SSL 6350 the functionality to be operated by just one person during a test, freeing up another technician to take on more jobs and be more productive. Ideal also for new MOT sites with limited space, the SSL 6350 has a lifting capacity of 3500kg and meets the DVSA requirements for testing of Class IV vehicles. The SSL 6350 is also a solution for current MOT stations wanting to bring their equipment up to date while minimising disruption to their businesses.

  • Southbound – New RMI Academy opens in Winchester  

    The Retail Motor Industry Federation (RMI) is to expand its MOT training offering by opening a new training centre in the South of England.

  • Site Audit snippets: Miscellaneous Equipment  

    Every MOT bay is required to retain and maintain a bunch of mandatory miscellaneous equipment. First let’s get the words from The MOT Testing Guide 6th Edition:

    5.6 Miscellaneous equipment

  • MOT overhaul means more changes for testers 

    New changes to the MOT testing rules mean that 65,000 MOT Testers must complete new annual training assessments to remain compliant.  In response, the Institute of the Motor Industry (IMI), has launched updated Tester training which includes a free eLearning course enabling Testers to access the new assessment via their smart device and qualify them to test under the new EU directive.  

Most read content


Search

Sign Up

For the latest news and updates from Aftermarket Magazine.


Poll

Where should the next Automechanika show be held?



Facebook


©DFA Media 1999-2019